BEST NEW AND OLD SXE HARDCORE BANDS

my favourites are

old: minor threat, gorilla biscuits and 7 seconds
new: casey jones, carry on, give up the ghost



whos yours??

Old: Youth of Today, Ten Yard Fight
New: Casey Jones

old:minor threat,uniform choice,chain of strength,
slapshot,crippled youth,7 seconds,ss decontrol,cro mags!

new:sportswear,true colors,hoods up,eyeball,mainstrike,
commitment crew,common cause,birds of a feather!

Old: Minor Threat, Gorrilla Biscuits, 7 Seconds

New: Good Clean Fun, Down To Nothing, Internal Affairs

Old: Youth of today, bold, minor threat, gorilla biscuits, 7 seconds, uniform choice.

New: Have Heart, Vitamin x, Bane, What Happens Next?.

New: Rise Against and Cancer Bats...That's all I can think of at the moment...

Old: Judge, Strife(they broke edge but who cares) and Project-X
New: HAVE HEART

casey jones broke edge?

In terms of time period, all my bands are listed corresponding to the year formed, not the year they broke up, or if they are still playing.

Old: Gorilla Biscuits, Minor Threat (like everyone else), SSD, Agnostic Front, and DYS.

Middle Years: Earth Crisis, Bane, Champion, OLC, Good Clean Fun, and Outbreak.

New: First Step, Kids Like Us, Righteous Jams, Have Heart, Down To Nothing, Stick To Your Guns, Winds Of Plague, The Warriors, The Red Baron, and xLOOKING FORWARDx.

And KyraJoy, do some research before you believe every stupid myspace rumor.
Casey Jones has not broken edge.
Throwdown has not broken edge. Although they have vastly changed their style from the early days and no longer include saying they are an edge band in their myspace profile, they still remain true.
And about the whole Liferuiner issue, so many rumors have floated around about that band, I can no longer believe any thing I hear about them. I saw them just a month or two ago and their singer still claimed they were all edge. Another issue is lot's of people are no longer including no random hookups and I feel this is the case in terms of Liferuiner. And if you are basing their breaking edge off of them removing their x's. Bands do it all the time. A perfect example of this is Bishop. Just because they no longer feel the need to include something any half brain dead person could figure out in their title, does not mean they broke edge.


Edit: Yes, I know Outbreak is actually semi-newish, but I was torn between grouping them in the new or middle. So I picked the middle. I do know the argument can be made against my selection but I truely don't care and don't wanna hear it.
But on the other hand, if you wish to debate (and I stress the dictionary definition of debate, 1. a formal contest in which the affirmative and negative sides of a proposition are advocated by opposing speakers) the claims I have made against bands breaking edge. I would be more then happy to listen.

My old favorite band is: Chain of Strenght,Youth of today
new: xBishopx, Good Clean Fun, xFilesx,Strife

Old: Minor Threat, Gorilla Biscuits

New: xLooking Forwardx, xDEATHSTARx, Casey Jones, Have Heart

Because being in the same room as someone who is not sXe means you can't be edge yourself

...?

What it comes down to is, whose band is it? Who writes all the songs? I'm gonna bet that for the majority of bands, it's not the drummer.

Depends whose message it is.